After the events in the first Scary Tales movie, Mr Longfellow (Joel D. Wynkoop) has moved on from his bogus job placement agency to a new venture, to allow him to tell his fantastical tales. Welcome to "Mr. Longfellow's Used Car Lot."
Unfortunately the movie Scary Tales: The Return of Mr. Longfellow is not yet available on Disney Plus.
| Directing | Jason Daly | Director |
| Directing | Michael Hoffman Jr. | Director |
| Production | Richard Cecere | Co-Producer |
| Production | Tim Ritter | Associate Producer |
| Production | Jason Daly | Executive Producer |
| Writing | Jason Daly | Screenplay |
| Writing | Richard Cecere | Screenplay |
| Writing | Michael Hoffman Jr. | Screenplay |
| Production | Joe Estevez | Associate Producer |
| Production | Robert Z'Dar | Associate Producer |
| Production | Michael Hoffman Jr. | Producer |
